Apparel Tips

Tough as Old Boots: 6 Most Durable Cowboy Boots

tough cowboy and dog
Written by Horse Rookie

Standing Tough

If you’re attending a one-off western wedding, maybe you only need your boots to hold up for a single night. For the rest of us, though, we want our cowboy boots to stick around for years.

Working the ranch, riding horses, and long days on the job shouldn’t be too much for your footwear. That’s why we put together a list of some of the toughest boots in the business.

6 Most Durable Cowboy Boots

  • Dan Post Parkston Steel Toe
  • Justin Mens Commander X5
  • Twisted X All Around
  • Ariat Fat Baby Heritage
  • Ariat Heritage Lacer III
  • Bogs Classic Mid Waterproof Boot

Dan Post Parkston Steel Toe Boot

The toughest work boot doesn’t need bells and whistles, and this no-frills option is one such example. At home on the ranch or in the office, the subtle brown leather exterior is as versatile as it is durable.

It features a steel toe, waterproof exterior, and an oil and heat resistant rubber outsole.

Click to see it at Amazon

This western boot can take a beating without looking beat up. Plus, the leather feels broken in from day one, and they come with a removable airflow orthotic insole.

PROS:

  • Classic and sharp
  • Look good with jeans tucked in or out
  • Neutral brown color

CONS:

  • Runs about ½ size small
  • Design may be too “basic” for some tastes

Click to see it on Amazon

Justin Mens Commander X5

The Commander X5 is a serious work boot that combines innovative safety and comfort features with a classic style for super comfortable cowboy boots.

Shaft contrast stitching helps this design stand out from other work boots.

Justin Commander X5

Click to see it at Amazon

The sole is made of Vibram — a blend that is resistant to heat, oil, and chemicals. Plus, it’s electrical hazard rated and meets ASTM F2413-11, 175, C75 EH safety footwear standards.

PROS: 

  • Electrical hazard rated
  • Steel toe boot
  • Super-tough outsoles

CONS:

  • Might be too wide for narrow feet
  • Sporty look may be too much for traditionalists

Read Customer Reviews on Amazon

Twisted X All Around

A rugged-yet-comfortable leather boot. The All Around by Twisted X holds up to all types of barn and farm duties, and the shaft is tough enough for slogging through mud and muck. These square toe cowboy boots have generous pull holes making them easy to get on.

 

Twisted-x-women

Click to see it on State Line Tack

A sturdy rubber sole and toe guard protect your toes from hard knocks. They also have an XSD composite shank that keeps you more stable on rough or slippery surfaces.

PROS:

  • Moisture-wicking insole
  • Substantial rubber outsole and toe guard
  • Memory foam interior is machine washable

CONS: 

  • Can run a bit small
  • Only comes in brown

Read Customer Reviews on State Line Tack

See why Twisted X also made our list of the 5 Best Boots for Long, Hard Days at the Horse Barn.

Ariat Fatbaby Heritage

For equestrians with wider feet, and those who prefer a more relaxed fit, try the Ariat Fatbaby western cowboy boot.

Fatbaby fans rave these boots require virtually no break in.

Ariat Fat Baby Heritage

Click to see this boot at Amazon

Not only is the outsole tough enough for years of hard work, they come in a wide variety of colors and patterns.

PROS:

  • Relaxed foot and shaft fit
  • 4LR support system for better cushioning
  • Lots of color options

CONS:

  • Shorter 8″ shaft is somewhere between paddock boots and tall riding boots
  • Style is too casual for most competitions

Read Customer Reviews on Amazon

See why the Fat Baby made our list of the 12 Most Comfortable Cowboy Boots.

Ariat Heritage Lacer III

The Ariat Heritage Lacer III isn’t as bulky as some of the other Ariat boots on this list, but it still holds up to years of riding, working, and hoofing it around town.

The fringed tongue is removable if you want a more english style.

Ariat Heritage Lacer III

Click to see this boot at Amazon

It’s got a sturdy stacked heel and cushioned insole, and the exterior is tough enough for everyday activities.

PROS:

  • Leather upper and durable rubber sole hold up over time
  • ATS technology provides superior support and stabilization
  • Pair with Ariat half chaps for a tall boot appearance

CONS:

  • Lace up versus zipper
  • No back pull strap

Read customer reviews on Amazon

See our detailed review of the Ariat Heritage Lacer III Paddock Boot.

online horse courses

Bogs Classic Mid Waterproof Boot

Cowboys don’t always wear a traditional cowboy boot. For the muddiest and muckiest of jobs, reach for the Bogs Classic Mid Waterproof Rain Boot.

Mud is no match for these ultra-durable muck boots.

Bogs Classic Waterproof

Click to see this boot at Amazon

Waterproof and windproof, these boots are built to survive the toughest (and wettest) conditions.

PROS:

  • Waterproof neoprene upper
  • Non-slip outsole for slick surfaces
  • Suitable for all seasons (down to minus 40F)
  • Anti-fungal, odor-resistant, and removable sock liner

CONS:

  • Seam up the back of the ankle may rub at first
  • Size up if you plan to wear thick socks

Check the latest price on Amazon

See why Bogs made our list of the 7 Best Muck Boots.

Parting Thoughts

Your boots should work as hard as you do, and now they finally will. When you invest in durable ‘kicks,’ it’s money well spent.

P.S. Enjoy this article? Trot on over to:

 
Love it? Share it!

About the author

Horse Rookie

I began riding horses at age six, and I'm just as infatuated (OK, more!) with the sport decades later. My AQHA gelding exemplifies the versatility of the breed -- reined cow horse, reining, roping, ranch riding, trail, dressage, and jumping. We're also dipping our toes (hooves) into Working Equitation!